Political commentary and analysis by Michael L. Wise, PhD
Comprehensive collection of articles spanning demographics, Israeli sovereignty, Middle East policy, and regional security analysis from 2005-2026.
Israel and the Jews must win the slogan war.
Wise argues that one word, "EVIL", best describes antisemites, anti-Zionists and Israel's enemies. He presents antisemitism as an ancient hatred that has rebranded itself in conspiracy theories, attacks and campus hostility, and contends that anti-Zionism singles out Jews by denying them the self-determination granted to other peoples, while separating it from legitimate criticism of Israeli policy.
He points to celebrations of the October 7 attacks and to the repression practiced by Hamas, Iran and Hezbollah, and cites Reagan's evil empire speech and Bush's Axis of Evil as precedents for naming evil plainly.
He then proposes a campaign: posters that pair the word with a label, such as EVIL Terrorists, EVIL Racists, EVIL Homophobes, EVIL Murderers and EVIL Antisemites, plus a consistent hashtag, bold shareable graphics, one-word replies to anti-Israel posts, and broad adoption by pro-Israel voices, as a way to win what he calls the slogan war.
If the conversation always begins with Israel justifying its existence or its actions, the other side has already won the opening move. Here's what to say.
Wise argues that Israel and the Jewish community are losing a slogan war, not because the facts are against them but because the battle is over perception. Short slogans such as "genocide", "apartheid" and "From the River to the Sea" spread far faster than detailed rebuttals, and he says they are built to delegitimize Israel rather than describe it.
He contends these labels do not fit Israel, noting that its Arab citizens vote, sit in parliament and serve as judges, and places them in a long line of antisemitic libels. Factual rebuttals are necessary, he says, but not enough.
He urges going on offense with accurate, memorable counter-slogans aimed at Islamist movements rather than Muslims as people. His examples tie Hamas, ISIS and Al-Qaeda to one ideology, link October 7 to 9/11, contrast 57 Muslim-majority countries with 15 million Jews worldwide, and include short lines such as "Jihad is not resistance." He asks readers to send in their own ideas.
Those 600 trucks of aid that enter the Gaza Strip each day should go to the Druze, not to Hamas.
Wise argues that the 600 aid trucks sent into Gaza each day pass through territory controlled by Hamas, which he says has diverted, taxed and exploited aid. Calling the convoy humanitarian is therefore a stretch, and in his view it helps Hamas keep its grip on Gazans who want to leave.
He contrasts this with needs he says the world ignores: Syrian Druze near the Golan, who face violence and food insecurity and openly identify with Israel and Israeli Druze; Egypt's worsening food crisis; and countries such as Chad, Madagascar, Sudan and Yemen that rank among the worst on the Global Hunger Index.
He criticizes the UN and EU for sending volume without accountability, citing aid diversion and allegations against UNRWA staff over October 7. He concludes that the daily trucks should be redirected to the Druze bordering the Golan.
Britain did not recognize Israel until 1950, two years after its founding, and was among the last Western democracies to do so. Part of a pattern.
Wise argues that Britain's century-long relationship with Jewish national aspirations has moved from a diplomatic promise to obstruction and, recently, open hostility, pointing to British steps he sees as partial boycotts of settlements and to the UK's recognition of a Palestinian Arab state.
He traces the history: the Balfour Declaration, written into the Mandate, was soon undercut by limits on Jewish immigration; the 1939 White Paper shut Palestine to Jewish refugees as the Holocaust approached; Britain abstained on the 1947 partition vote, British officers led the Arab Legion against Israel, and recognition came only in 1950. He also argues that Jordan, carved from the Mandate by Britain, is effectively a Palestinian Arab state.
He says British accusations of genocide after October 7 apply a standard Britain never applied to its own wars. While acknowledging the record has complexity, he urges that this history be part of the debate.
The dilemma facing Washington and Jerusalem: A nuclear-capable Iran that still funds proxies from Lebanon to Yemen is not a foreign-policy result. It is a failure. What can the US do?
Wise argues that efforts at regime change in Iran have failed because they never matched the scale of the problem. He describes the Islamic Republic as a layered system built to crush dissent, says inconsistent American policy across administrations taught it to wait out pressure, and notes that repeated uprisings were crushed while the opposition stayed fragmented.
Drawing on the Soviet collapse, Romania in 1989, the 1953 coup and Libya, he concludes that airstrikes cannot topple a governing system and that urging revolt without organized support endangers ordinary Iranians.
He proposes sustained allied sanctions tied to clear conditions, direct support for Iranians through secure communications and independent media, incentives for the Revolutionary Guards to fracture, an opposition united around a platform Iranians own, and cutting off proxy financing. He presents the Trump administration's new economic offensive as a major escalation, and warns that outsiders cannot install a legitimate government.
החובה שלא נוחה לכולם
Halakhic and historical analysis of Haredi military service: in a milchemet mitzvah there is no basis for a blanket exemption, especially after October 7.
Wise argues that the blanket exemption of Haredi yeshiva students from IDF service, begun in 1948 to rebuild Torah learning after the Holocaust, has no basis in Jewish law. Citing the Mishnah, the Jerusalem Talmud and Maimonides, he says a defensive war obligates every able person, and that saving lives overrides nearly all other commandments.
He points to Torah scholars who were also military leaders, from Joshua and King David to the Hasmoneans and Shmuel HaNagid, and to the growth of exemptions from 400 in 1948 to 63,000. He rebuts the Haredi leadership's arguments in turn and suggests their opposition reflects distrust of young people and a wish to keep control, not halakha.
He allows exemptions for individuals who genuinely study day and night, acknowledges the IDF's own shortcomings, and cites Netzah Yehuda and the new Hasmonean Brigade as proof that service and observance can coexist.
Anti-Semitic hate speech and terrorism must be punished. When world leaders call for immediate Palestinian Arab statehood in the aftermath of October 7, they send a chilling message: that terrorism works.
Responding to Australian Prime Minister Albanese's rejection of any link between recognizing a Palestinian Arab state and the antisemitic attack at Bondi, Wise offers ten responses and argues that granting statehood after October 7 would reward terrorism and signal that violence works.
He points to the 2005 Gaza withdrawal, which he says brought thousands of rockets and the diversion of international aid into tunnels and weapons, to Hamas's charter, and to the Palestinian Authority's payments to terrorists' families. He says Palestinian Arab leaders rejected past offers, including Camp David in 2000 and the 2008 Olmert proposal, because they refused to accept Israel's legitimacy, and that Israel faces a double standard.
He calls for accountability for Hamas leaders, de-radicalization of Palestinian Arab society like that of postwar Germany and Japan, and minimum conditions for any future leadership, including renouncing terror and recognizing Israel as a Jewish state.
Emperor Hadrian rebranded Judea to annihilate Jewish identity; modern pan-Arabists rebranded themselves to appropriate that identity. Analysis of how the Palestinian identity was created as a diplomatic weapon and the historical falsehoods codified into modern diplomacy.
Wise argues that Hadrian's renaming of Judea as Syria Palaestina after the Bar Kochba revolt, meant to sever Jews from their land, lives on in today's claim that Palestine is ancient and Israel an imposter. He sees UN Security Council Resolution 2803, which endorses a pathway to Palestinian statehood, as the latest example.
He cites statements by Zahir Muhsein, Ahmed Shukairy, Hafez al-Assad, Arafat and others denying a distinct Palestinian nation, and says the 1922 Mandate set the land aside as the Jewish National Home. He describes Palestinian identity as a tactic adopted after Arab military defeats, and the Oslo Accords as a Trojan horse.
He warns that accepting the land as Palestinian turns every Israeli community into an occupation, and urges Israeli diplomats to confront Security Council members and the media with these admissions and to insist on the name Eretz Yisrael.
Analysis of how Jihadist movements weaponize intersectionality frameworks to advance anti-democratic agendas while exploiting Western progressive activists who would be among the first victims of successful Jihadist conquest.
Wise argues that Israel should stop defending itself against false accusations and go on offense by exposing how Jihadist movements exploit intersectionality, the coalition of progressive causes. He says LGBTQ+, feminist and anti-racist activists are allying with movements whose goals under Sharia would destroy their own freedoms, and that these allies would be targeted once Israel was gone.
He supports this with an account of fourteen centuries of Islamic conquest, Quranic verses about non-believers, the Muslim Brotherhood's strategy of building institutions inside democracies, Iran's stated aim of destroying Israel, and Hamas as part of a global network. He says many Muslims are peaceful but estimates committed Jihadists at 5 to 10 percent.
He calls on Israel to document the funding and connections behind these groups, lead an education campaign on this history, and distinguish peaceful Muslims and reformers from Islamists.
Strategic proposal for ending the propaganda war by declaring sovereignty over Judea and Samaria, terminating Oslo Accords, ending military occupation, and extending civil rights to all residents under Israeli law.
Wise argues that while Israel is winning on the battlefield, it is losing the propaganda war, and that the root cause is its military rule over Judea and Samaria. In his view, no public relations effort can succeed while an occupation, however benevolent, remains in place, because it cannot be defended in the court of public opinion.
He proposes that Israel declare sovereignty over Judea and Samaria, void the Oslo Accords, and disband the Palestinian Authority. Arab residents without criminal records could apply for permanent residency with blue ID cards, gaining civil law protection, social benefits, and local voting rights, though not national Knesset votes while hostile neighbors seek Israel's destruction.
Citing the Gaza withdrawal and October 7th, he contends this would show terrorism leads nowhere, end the occupation narrative, and turn Israel's biggest propaganda liability into a strategic asset.
Analysis of military service requirements and demographic considerations for Israel's defense needs.
Wise argues that Jewish law offers no basis for a blanket exemption of Haredi men from IDF service. Drawing on the Mishnah, the Jerusalem Talmud, Maimonides, and the principle of saving lives, he contends that defending Israel against attack obligates every able-bodied person, and he points to Torah scholars who were also military leaders, from Moses and the Maccabees to Samuel Hanagid.
He traces how exemptions grew from a few hundred in 1948 to tens of thousands, and says current Haredi opposition stems from fear of secularization and a desire for communal control rather than halakha. He rebuts several common arguments, including that Torah study alone protects the nation.
While supporting exemptions for those truly learning full time, he calls for the IDF to keep providing religious accommodations, citing Netzah Yehuda and the Hasmonaim Battalion, and for the Haredi community to share in Israel's defense.
Commentary on international interference in Israeli affairs and sovereignty issues.
Wise sharply criticizes French President Emmanuel Macron for organizing, with Saudi Arabia, an international push to establish a Palestinian Arab state. He argues that France's own colonial history leaves Macron no moral standing to accuse Israel of genocide, and that such a state would quickly be dominated by Hamas and other groups seeking Israel's destruction.
He contends that October 7 ended the idea that territorial concessions bring peace, and points to Arabs in Israel and Jerusalem who, he says, overwhelmingly prefer living under Israeli rule rather than the Palestinian Authority.
Wise attributes Macron's stance to an adviser long lobbying for Palestinian statehood, to domestic pressures from France's Muslim population, and to low popularity at home. He accuses Macron of ignoring Iran's nuclear progress and mockingly suggests France consider its own internal problems instead.
Historical analysis proposing alternative approaches to current conflicts based on past precedents from 1982.
Wise recalls how, in 1982, Yasser Arafat and thousands of PLO fighters were given safe passage out of Beirut to Tunisia, only to return years later under the Oslo Accords. He argues that Hamas now faces a similar defeat and that a comparable exit may be the best path forward.
He proposes a non-negotiable offer: Hamas returns all the hostages and, in exchange, its leaders and their families receive safe passage to a friendly host country. He expects that the rest of Gaza's population would then willingly accept offers to emigrate, stressing that no one would be forced to leave.
Wise envisions Gaza, freed of Arab control, becoming a hub for commerce and tourism, and insists Israel must learn from past Gaza mistakes and never again agree to an Oslo-style accord.
Critique of international humanitarian organizations' response to Israeli hostages in Gaza.
Wise argues that before any further hostage negotiations or ceasefire with Hamas, the International Red Cross must gain access to all hostages so Israel knows who is alive and who has been murdered. He calls on governments, human rights groups, and mediators to join that demand.
He faults the Red Cross for never visiting the hostages held since October 7, noting its only visible role has been transporting freed hostages amid armed terrorists. He links this to what he sees as a long pattern of disregard for Jewish suffering, citing the organization's own admission of failure during the Holocaust and its decades-long exclusion of Magen David Adom.
Wise warns that rewarding hostage-taking encourages future terror, and urges Jews and humanitarians to withhold donations from the Red Cross until such visits take place.
Commentary on civilian displacement and the need for alternative solutions for Gaza residents.
Wise argues that most Gazans want to escape Hamas rule, but that the US, UN, EU, Egypt, and aid organizations are effectively keeping them trapped in order to preserve the two-state agenda. He contends that aid money has been diverted by Hamas into tunnels, weapons, and personal wealth, and that past ceasefires only let Hamas prepare for October 7.
He welcomes the removal of Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, whom he portrays as too aligned with the Biden administration's ceasefire pressure.
As a solution, Wise proposes helping Gazans who wish to leave relocate abroad, arguing transport would be relatively cheap and that the many Muslim-majority countries have room to absorb them. He warns that rebuilding Gaza with its population in place would lead to another war, and expresses hope that a second Trump administration will pursue the one-Jewish-state vision outlined by David Friedman.
Policy proposals for territorial governance using a Puerto Rico-style model for gradual integration.
Wise proposes a gradual path to Israeli sovereignty in Judea and Samaria. Rather than declaring sovereignty at once, Israel would first invite Arab residents of selected areas, such as neighborhoods in Gush Etzion, Ma'ale Adumim, Ariel, or the Jordan Valley, to apply for permanent residency with a blue Israeli ID card, bringing benefits like healthcare, national insurance, and local, but not national, voting rights.
He argues that Israel keeps losing the information war as long as military rule, seen as occupation, continues, and that withdrawal has already failed in Gaza. He says demographic fears that once blocked annexation have been debunked.
Pointing to Jerusalem Arabs' preference for living in Israel, he expects demand for residency to spread village by village, undermining the Palestinian Authority and Hamas. Once that happens, he argues, Israel could declare sovereignty with the support of a non-hostile population.
Analysis of why Israel must achieve decisive victory rather than accepting ceasefires that embolden enemies.
Wise argues that the world has never allowed Israel to win a war outright, and that ending conflicts with ceasefires and armistices has only invited the next attack. He reviews Israel's wars from 1948 through the five Gaza conflicts, contending that each time international pressure denied a decisive victory and let enemies such as Hamas and Hezbollah rebuild.
This time, he says, nearly all of Israel understands it must achieve total victory and not let Hamas survive in Gaza. He describes Hamas as largely defeated, rejects safe passage for Sinwar, and says only military pressure can secure the hostages' return.
Wise predicts Iran and its proxies will be deterred by an Israeli victory, opposes a Palestinian Authority takeover of Gaza, and argues that only after defeating Hamas can a new Middle East emerge.
Examination of international bias against Israel and the roots of persistent anti-Israel sentiment.
Wise argues that, despite broad American support for Israel, international bodies such as the UN, the international courts, the European Union, and parts of the US State Department are working to keep Israel from defeating Hamas and Hezbollah and to push it toward a Palestinian state he considers dangerous.
He attributes this hostility to a long history of attempts to destroy the Jewish people, and to resentment of Israel's remarkable post-Holocaust success, which he says challenges Christian and Islamic replacement theologies. In his view, the Palestinian cause became a new vehicle for old antisemitism.
Wise criticizes media claims about Gaza, which he calls lies, US pressure on Israel, and university leaders who failed to confront pro-Hamas campus protests. He closes hoping Israel will defeat Hamas, bring the hostages home, and see peace expand through the Abraham Accords.
Advocating for voluntary relocation opportunities for Gaza residents to escape Hamas rule.
Wise opens with his grandson, serving in Gaza, warning that if displaced Gazans return north, another war will follow within a few years. Wise argues that Israel must finally win a war: Hamas and its supporters must be removed from Gaza, and peaceful Gazans who want to leave should be helped to find homes in new host countries.
He criticizes international pressure for a ceasefire and for handing Gaza to third parties or a Palestinian state, pointing to a century of Arab rejection of a Jewish state. Drawing on his demographic work, he argues Gaza's real population is well below official claims and that polls show many Gazans would prefer to live elsewhere.
Citing the Jews who fled or were expelled from Muslim countries after 1948, and other displaced populations, he calls on Muslim countries to open their doors and urges the United States to lead support for relocation.
Critique of the two-state solution paradigm and its repeated failures in practice.
Wise notes that since October 7 the Hebrew term conceptzia, a governing assumption that blinds leaders to warning signs, has mostly been used to blame Netanyahu and the military leadership. He traces the term to the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
He argues that these critics hold their own dangerous conceptzia: the belief that a Palestinian state and land-for-peace deals will bring peace. He traces its failures from the 1937 Peel Commission and 1947 partition plan through Khartoum, Oslo, the 2000 Lebanon withdrawal, the 2005 Gaza disengagement and the maritime deal with Lebanon.
After October 7, he says, most Israelis now see Arab hostility as opposition to any Jewish sovereignty rather than a land dispute. He urges Israel, once Hamas is eliminated, to declare sovereignty over Judea and Samaria with civil and religious rights for all residents, and predicts expanded Abraham Accords.
Position paper on post-conflict governance and the path to sustainable peace.
Responding to the Biden administration's push for a Palestinian state as part of the "Day After" plan, Wise argues that an Israeli withdrawal from Judea and Samaria would turn the area into a haven for terrorism, repeating Gaza's experience after 2005 on a larger scale.
He proposes that Israel declare sovereignty west of the Jordan River once its goals in Gaza are met, with Hamas, Fatah and the Palestinian Authority removed. Citing precedents in Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, he would let Arab residents apply for Blue Israel ID cards, giving full civil and religious rights and local self-government but no vote in national elections, alongside economic incentives modeled on the Abraham Accords and Puerto Rico's incentives code.
He argues official population figures are inflated, suggests helping Gazans who wish to relocate, and predicts sovereignty would end the conflict and widen regional normalization.
Strategic planning for post-conflict scenarios and long-term security arrangements.
Wise says Israel's stated war goals in Gaza, freeing the hostages, eliminating Hamas and ending the threat from Gaza, are proper but do not address the root cause of the conflict. He argues that Arab terrorism aims to frighten Israel into accepting a two-state solution, and that it has worked before, as with the 2005 withdrawal from Gaza.
Calling the two-state idea a delusion exposed by October 7, he argues that the long military occupation of Judea and Samaria fuels terrorism and that Israel should declare sovereignty there, showing terrorists that their agenda is a dead end.
Arab residents, he suggests, could receive Blue Israel ID cards like most Jerusalem Arabs, run their local affairs and elect Knesset observers, similar to Puerto Rico and Washington, D.C. He rejects apartheid charges and predicts expanded Abraham Accords.
Historical analysis of how international pressure has prevented Israeli military victories.
In this short teaser, Wise argues that Israel must destroy Hamas, both for its own sake and to keep its credibility as an ally of Sunni states in their conflict with Iran.
Argument against premature ceasefires that allow terrorists to regroup and rearm.
Wise argues that unconditional surrender by Hamas is the only humane path left for Gaza's population, and that if Hamas refuses, it will be destroyed. He accuses Hamas of holding civilians as human shields, including at Al Shifa Hospital, and of stopping them from fleeing south.
He criticizes the UN General Assembly's demand for an immediate ceasefire that did not mention Hamas, citing objections from Czech and Israeli officials, and asks whether the UN would have sought a ceasefire to let Hitler or Japan regroup.
Listing conflicts in Syria, Yemen, Africa, Ukraine, Myanmar and elsewhere where the UN and humanitarian groups have not demanded ceasefires, he argues Israel is held to a unique standard. He concludes that Israel must defend itself against enemies sworn to its destruction, and that a world blind to other wars cannot dictate its course.
Call for Hamas's unconditional surrender as the only path to genuine humanitarian relief.
Writing after the October 7 massacre, Wise argues that Israelis are united in seeking Hamas's total destruction, and that the most humanitarian outcome would be for Hamas to surrender unconditionally before Israel's coming ground assault.
He says Hamas has never respected the laws of war and uses civilians as human shields, while Israel warns residents before strikes and has allowed aid convoys into southern Gaza. He argues that the earlier approach of limited rounds ending in ceasefires has failed, and compares the choice facing Hamas to the German and Japanese surrenders of 1945.
Surrender, he argues, would bring the hostages home, free Gazans from Hamas and could let Gaza prosper. He expects Hamas to refuse and to bear responsibility for what follows, but urges Israel to make the offer anyway.
Demographic analysis challenging inflated population figures commonly cited in media.
Wise challenges media claims that Gaza has 2 million or more residents, arguing the true number is at most 1.7 million. He cites a 2005 study by the American Israel Demographic Group, published by BESA, which found at most 1.1 million then, against Palestinian Authority claims of up to 2 million.
He says Israeli demographers who echoed the higher figures admitted relying on the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics rather than independent research, and notes that the claimed total barely changed in 18 years. He argues that emigration from Gaza, documented at about 11,000 a year when Israel controlled the crossings, has likely grown, so even 1.7 million may be too high.
Accurate figures matter, he argues, to counter inflated casualty claims, to inform Egypt about potential refugees, and to show Israel's positive Jewish demographic trends.
Detailed proposal for territorial governance based on the U.S. territories model.
Wise argues that the two-state solution, still promoted by the Biden administration, has repeatedly failed and is now obsolete, and that withdrawing from Judea and Samaria would risk creating a terrorist state, as the Gaza experience showed.
He proposes that Israel declare sovereignty and let the area's Arab residents apply for Blue Israel ID cards. Holders would have full civil and religious rights, run their local affairs, and elect non-voting representatives to the Knesset, modeled on the delegates of Puerto Rico and other U.S. territories in Congress. He argues that full Knesset voting rights are too risky while parts of the Muslim world seek Israel's destruction.
He pairs this with economic incentives modeled on the Abraham Accords and Puerto Rico's incentives code, cites earlier sovereignty precedents in Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, and dismisses apartheid accusations.
Comprehensive strategy for eliminating terrorism through territorial and administrative changes.
Wise argues that terrorism against Israel is driven by the belief that violence will push Israel toward a two-state solution, which he calls a delusion. He points to the Oslo Accords and the 2005 Gaza withdrawal as concessions won by terror, and says the Gaza pullout brought Hamas to power, thousands of rockets, and repeated wars.
As long as Israeli, American and European officials keep promising a Palestinian state, he contends, terrorists will believe more violence brings it closer. His remedy is for Israel to end military rule and declare sovereignty over Judea and Samaria, which he says would make terrorism a dead end and leave remaining crime to the police.
For Arab residents, he proposes a status like that of most Jerusalem Arabs: Israeli ID cards, benefits and local self-government, but no national vote while neighbors seek Israel's destruction. He rejects the charge that this would be apartheid.
Historical and linguistic analysis of proper territorial nomenclature.
Wise proposes that the territory variously called the West Bank, the occupied or disputed territories, or Judea and Samaria be called simply Judea, split into Northern and Southern Judea on either side of Jerusalem. He suggests news headlines, and even the Shomron Regional Council, adopt these names.
To make the case, he traces the name Samaria from the ancient Northern Kingdom through the Assyrian conquest and the Samaritans, of whom he says about 800 remain today and claim no land. He then reviews the modern record: the British Mandate, the creation of Transjordan, the 1947 partition plan, Jordan's 1948 occupation, and its 1950 annexation, which he says coined the term West Bank and was recognized by only two countries.
He concludes that once the area is called Judea, many will understand that it is part of Israel.
Personal family history illustrating the Jewish refugee experience and UNRWA's role.
Wise argues that UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, is a major obstacle to peace, and criticizes the Biden administration for resuming its funding. Unlike other UN refugee bodies, he contends, it keeps refugee status alive across generations as a political weapon against Israel, and he accuses it of cooperating with Hamas, inciting hatred in its schools, and mismanagement.
He contrasts this with the Jews forced out of Muslim countries after 1948, who got no international help, and then tells his own family's story. His grandparents, from families rooted in Jerusalem for generations, including that of Joseph Rivlin, an early builder of neighborhoods outside the Old City walls, were driven out by Arab violence and became what he calls Jewish Palestinian refugees. His wife's family fled Sheikh Jarrah in 1948.
Those refugees, he says, rebuilt their lives without subsidies. He hopes UNRWA ends and Arab neighbors absorb Palestinian refugees.
Critical analysis of UNRWA's perpetuation of refugee status for political purposes.
Wise argues that UNRWA is a major obstacle to peace. Created in 1949 to help Arabs who left Israel settle in neighboring Arab states, it has instead, he says, prolonged the conflict by keeping refugees from integrating and sustaining a false hope of return. He cites claims that few of those it counts as refugees meet the criteria, notes it has admitted cooperating with Hamas, and objects to President Biden's renewed funding.
He contrasts this with his own family. All four of his grandparents, he writes, were driven from Jerusalem by Arab violence in the 1920s and fled to New York as penniless Jewish Palestinian refugees, and his wife's family was forced out of Sheikh Jarrah in 1948.
By UNRWA's definition, he says, many relatives could count as refugees, yet they built successful lives without subsidies. He hopes Palestinian refugees become citizens of Arab countries and UNRWA disappears.
Personal family history demonstrating long-standing Jewish presence in Jerusalem neighborhoods.
Wise answers claims that Israeli Jews are colonizing or Judaizing Sheikh Jarrah by arguing that his family's history undermines them. His mother was born there in 1921, in the Shimon HaTzadik neighborhood, a Jewish community built around the ancient sage's tomb on land Jews bought in 1876. It stayed Jewish, he says, until 1948, when the Jordanian army drove the residents out and Arabs occupied their homes. His wife was also born there, and her father shielded her as Jordanian shells hit their house.
He then reviews decades of litigation: a 1970 law letting Jews reclaim property lost in 1948, court rulings from 1976 onward upholding Jewish ownership with Arab residents as protected tenants, a rival claim rejected over deeds the court found forged, and 2021 eviction orders that sparked protests and, he says, helped ignite the Gaza war.
He ends cautiously optimistic, citing the Abraham Accords.
Historical context for Sheikh Jarrah property disputes based on personal family experience.
Wise rejects claims that Israeli Jews are colonizing Sheikh Jarrah or Judaizing Jerusalem, arguing that his family's history shows a long Jewish presence there. His mother was born in 1921 in the neighborhood's Shimon HaTzadik section, where Jews bought land in 1876 and which, he says, stayed Jewish until the Jordanian army drove residents out in 1948. His grandparents left Jerusalem in 1927 to escape anti-Jewish violence, and his wife, also born there, was shielded by her father as Jordanian shells hit their home.
He traces the legal history since 1970: a law allowing Jews to reclaim seized property, court rulings upholding Jewish ownership with Arab residents as protected tenants, deeds the court found forged, and 2021 eviction orders that led to protests and international pressure.
He closes cautiously optimistic, pointing to the Abraham Accords with the UAE and Bahrain.
Analysis of anti-Israel sentiment within Democratic Party politics and intersectionality movement.
Wise asks how support for Israel, once bipartisan, became a partisan issue, pointing to Democrats who welcomed a CAIR gala and presidential candidates who skipped the AIPAC conference. He blames intersectionality, a concept he says arose to address the oppression of women of color, which enemies of Israel began using in 2014 to cast Palestinians as victims of white Zionist colonialism and tie their cause to movements like Black Lives Matter, spreading anti-Zionism on campuses and in schools.
He rejects the apartheid label, arguing that Israel guarantees minority rights, that Arab citizens serve as lawmakers, judges and professionals, that security measures respond to terrorism, and that most Arab university students in Israel are women. Palestinian society, he says, is far less tolerant of women and gay people.
He urges rank-and-file Democrats not to let this movement hijack their party and calls for support for Israel to be bipartisan again.
Critique of Jewish individuals and organizations that actively undermine Israel.
Wise applies the label "fake Jews" to Jews he says work to harm Israel and the Jewish people, for example by backing the BDS movement and portraying Israel as an apartheid or genocidal state. He places them in a long line of Jews who sided with their people's enemies, and connects the idea to the Kabbalistic concept of the Erev Rav and a daily prayer against slanderers.
He praises President Trump's record on Israel, including moving the US embassy to Jerusalem, leaving the Iran nuclear deal, and recognizing Israeli sovereignty over the Golan, and criticizes Jews who attack him.
He then names many he puts in this category, including Richard Falk and Norman Finkelstein, Israeli groups such as Peace Now and B'tselem, Jewish Democrats in Congress who skipped the embassy opening, Bernie Sanders, Reform movement leaders, and groups including J Street, Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow.
Commentary on Jewish individuals and organizations that undermine Israel through false narratives.
Analysis of Trump administration's Middle East peace efforts and sovereignty alternatives.
Wise argues that the Trump administration's search for a Middle East peace deal should not end in a two-state solution. He says support for a Palestinian state rests on false demographic data and unfounded forecasts, and such a state would become a hostile, Gaza-like terrorist entity backed by Israel's enemies.
He says Israel and the West Bank are 67 percent Jewish, with Jewish fertility exceeding non-Jewish fertility, and questions theories that a large minority changes a state's character, pointing to centuries of Jewish survival as small minorities. He also contends that Arabs there value holding Israeli identity cards and would welcome fuller participation in Israeli society, provided minorities obey the law and reject violence.
He proposes Israeli sovereignty over Judea and Samaria, noting options such as immediate or phased annexation, with residents becoming permanent residents or possibly regaining Jordanian citizenship, and presents this as the real path to peace.
Proposal for single-state solution maintaining Jewish character while extending rights.
Responding to a New York Times article, Wise disputes the claim that Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank would end Israel's status as a Jewish democratic state. He argues that the West Bank's Arab population is under 1.7 million rather than three million, saying the higher figure comes from inflated Palestinian Authority counts, and cites data showing Jewish fertility now exceeds Arab fertility.
He rejects the apartheid charge, pointing to Israel's Declaration of Independence and to Arab citizens serving as lawmakers, ministers, judges and community leaders.
He proposes that after sovereignty, West Bank Arabs receive full civil and religious rights and run their own municipal affairs, but gain citizenship and national voting rights only once regional violence ends and Arab leaders recognize Israel as a Jewish state. He argues that a world blind to real apartheid cannot dictate how Israel preserves itself.
Call for Islamic reformation and moderate Muslim leadership in regional peace efforts.
Wise acknowledges that many Muslims are peaceful, productive members of society, but argues that these moderates have been overshadowed by extremist movements seeking to impose Sharia law and establish a caliphate. He traces what he calls a violent storm in the Muslim world back to Islam's early expansion and succession struggles, and lists conflicts, civil wars and terror attacks across many countries today.
He contends that the UN and other bodies ignore abuses in Muslim countries while condemning Israel, where he says the Muslim minority has full rights. He argues that Islamist rejection of any Jewish sovereignty is the true heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and backs Netanyahu's demand that peace include recognition of Israel as a Jewish state.
He concludes that genuine peace requires an end to incitement, and hopes global communications might spur an Islamic reformation like those Judaism and Christianity underwent.
Comprehensive refutation of apartheid accusations against Israel.
Prompted by Hamas accusing President Trump of encouraging apartheid, Wise argues that calling Israel an apartheid state corrupts the term and distorts Israeli society. He points to the Declaration of Independence's promise of equal rights, Israel's diverse population, Arabs and Jews mixing freely in hospitals and malls, Arab-run public schools, and Muslims serving as lawmakers, ministers, judges and professionals.
On the West Bank, he recounts its history from the 1922 Mandate through Jordanian occupation, the 1967 war and the Arab rejection at Khartoum, then the Oslo Accords. He argues that Israeli checkpoints and barriers are security measures against terrorism, not racial oppression.
He concludes that the real apartheid lies in the Palestinian Authority's effort to keep Jews out of areas it controls.
Critical analysis of demographic projections used to support two-state solution arguments.
Wise argues that warnings of a demographic catastrophe if Israel declares sovereignty over Judea and Samaria rest on fake demography. He criticizes demographers Sergio DellaPergola and Arnon Soffer, who he says relied on inflated Palestinian Authority statistics, and recalls how a 2003 meeting with Soffer first convinced him of the danger.
He describes joining Bennett Zimmerman on research published by the BESA Center, which found 1.41 million Arabs in the West Bank as of December 2004, far fewer than the figures then claimed. He says Nicholas Eberstadt verified the findings, they were presented to Knesset committees, and the critics eventually admitted, at least privately, that they were correct. He adds that Jewish fertility now exceeds Arab fertility and Jewish births have risen sharply.
He concludes that policymakers need accurate numbers, and that Jewish demographic momentum now supports sovereignty.
Proposal for single-state solution maintaining Jewish character while extending rights, also published on Israpundit.
Responding to a New York Times article, Wise disputes the claim that Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank would end Israel's status as a Jewish democratic state. He argues that the West Bank's Arab population is under 1.7 million rather than three million, saying the higher figure comes from inflated Palestinian Authority counts, and cites data showing Jewish fertility now exceeds Arab fertility.
He rejects the apartheid charge, pointing to Israel's Declaration of Independence and to Arab citizens serving as lawmakers, ministers, judges and community leaders.
He proposes that after sovereignty, West Bank Arabs receive full civil and religious rights and run their own municipal affairs, but gain citizenship and national voting rights only once regional violence ends and Arab leaders recognize Israel as a Jewish state. He argues that a world blind to real apartheid cannot dictate how Israel preserves itself.
Personal family history demonstrating long-standing Jewish presence in Jerusalem neighborhoods, also published on Israpundit.
Wise argues that claims Israel is colonizing or Judaizing Jerusalem's Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood erase its Jewish history, drawing on his family's story. His mother was born there in 1921 in the Shimon HaTzadik neighborhood, built around the ancient sage's tomb, and his wife was also born there before Jewish families fled during the War of Independence.
He recounts the 1876 Jewish land purchase, an Ottoman census recording Jewish families there, and the Jordanian army driving Jews out in 1948. He then traces decades of Israeli court rulings upholding Jewish ownership, including a finding that an Arab claimant's Ottoman deeds were forged, and the eviction orders that prompted protests and helped spark the recent Gaza war.
He concludes that his family history undermines Arab ownership claims, while expressing cautious optimism about regional peace after the Abraham Accords.
Personal narrative about family history in Sheikh Jarrah and property rights.
Wise answers the charge that Israeli Jews are "colonizing" Sheikh Jarrah with his own family history. His mother was born there in 1921, in the Shimon Ha'Tzadik section that grew up around the tomb of Shimon Ha'Tzadik. Jews bought the site in 1876, and an Ottoman census in 1905 counted 97 Jewish families there. They remained until 1948, when the Jordanian army drove them out and Arabs occupied their homes.
He recounts the anti-Jewish violence his relatives lived through, then the legal record from 1970 on: Israeli courts repeatedly upheld Jewish ownership, gave Arab residents protected-tenant status, and later ordered evictions for unpaid rent. The pending evictions were one of the sparks of the 11-day Gaza war in 2021.
His conclusion is that this documented Jewish ownership undermines the claim that Israel is "Judaizing" Jerusalem, and that the accusations are another attempt to erase a Jewish community's history.
Analysis of the broader context behind recent Israeli-Palestinian tensions.
Wise answers the charge that Israeli Jews are "colonizing" Sheikh Jarrah with his own family history. His mother was born there in 1921, in the Shimon Ha'Tzadik section that grew up around the tomb of Shimon Ha'Tzadik. Jews bought the site in 1876, and an Ottoman census in 1905 counted 97 Jewish families there. They remained until 1948, when the Jordanian army drove them out and Arabs occupied their homes.
He recounts the anti-Jewish violence his relatives lived through, then the legal record from 1970 on: Israeli courts repeatedly upheld Jewish ownership, gave Arab residents protected-tenant status, and later ordered evictions for unpaid rent. The pending evictions were one of the sparks of the 11-day Gaza war in 2021.
His conclusion is that this documented Jewish ownership undermines the claim that Israel is "Judaizing" Jerusalem, and that the accusations are another attempt to erase a Jewish community's history.
Early analysis of demographic trends and their implications for Israeli policy.
Writing about Ariel Sharon's Disengagement Plan, Wise warns that any two-state arrangement giving the Palestinian Authority sovereignty over the West Bank carries an overlooked risk: the arrival of 2 to 2.5 million Palestinian refugees within a few years, drawn by international support. He notes that recent studies put the current West Bank population at no more than 1.35 million, so there is no demographic threat today.
He predicts that such an influx would lead Israeli Arabs to identify with the Palestinian state and press for more rights, while international pressure would grow for Israel to cede territory, including parts of the Galilee and Negev. He expects many Israeli Jews, starting with left-wing advocates of separation, to emigrate.
He concludes that Israel could end up choosing between capitulation and full-scale war, and that Sharon may be unwittingly serving Abu Mazen's aim of destroying Israel.